Join the movement to shine a light on dark money in politics.
Phoenix Review

The Phoenix Review provides analysis on the presence of right-wing forces shaping Bay Area politics. Learn more about the billionaire agenda in short takes from the Bay Area's most insightful political observers

Featured

Everyday People Are Saving San Francisco

Everyday People Are Saving San Francisco

Dean Preston

You wouldn’t know it from corporate media, but there’s a mobilized, determined movement protecting San Francisco from a deepening crisis under a rising authoritarian government. Everyday people -- organizers, protestors, activists, and labor leaders -- are doing the real work of fighting back against the ethnic cleansing campaign

What the Beya Alcaraz Saga Tells Us About Daniel Lurie

What the Beya Alcaraz Saga Tells Us About Daniel Lurie

Lincoln Mitchell

The brief saga of Isabella “Beya” Alcaraz in San Francisco reveals something about the mayoral administration of Daniel Lurie. For those of you who have been paying attention to other things in recent weeks, following the recall of Joel Engardio, the supervisor for District Four, which includes most of the

JJ Smith and the Astroturf Network

JJ Smith became a local internet star by posting videos of drug users in the city’s long-troubled Tenderloin neighborhood. Smith’s videos became fodder for members of the Astroturf Network as it attacked progressive elected officials including former District Attorney Chesa Boudin and Supervisors Connie Chan, Aaron Peskin and

Garry Tan 2.0

Not long after the new year began, political provocateur and Pied Piper of right-wing San Francisco Garry Tan announced his departure from Astroturf group, GrowSF. Using his famously hyperactive X/Twitter account, Tan issued a terse message. He was abandoning local politics to spend more time in Washington, D.C.

Gil Duran Talks Techno-Fascism

Gil Duran was the first journalist to identify the strange right-wing beliefs being enthusiastically embraced by Bay Area tech leaders. The Network State, a scheme for tech elites to exit democracy and create their own sovereign states, served as a blueprint for their recent involvement in San Francisco elections. As

Moving Beyond the Doom Loop

Mayor Daniel Lurie faces a choice. He can continue to embrace the doom loop narrative instrumental to his election victory, or declare victory it and take on the hard work of governance. The doom loop narrative reframed how much of the country and world viewed San Francisco politics, and sought,

All the President’s Men

Mayor Daniel Lurie raised eyebrows when he announced that Sam Altman, chief executive of OpenAI, as a co-chair for his transition team. Although many expected the mayor to follow through on his promises to seek advice from the tech industry as he attempted to “open San Francisco for business,” the

San Francisco’s Right-Wing and Trump

Biden’s comments, a bit late and more than a dollar short, were a clear shot at billionaire Elon Musk and the tech barons now surrounding President Donald Trump. Simply being extremely wealthy does not an oligarch make; undue influence does. Musk is a classic example, acting on Trump’s

Mr. Tan Goes to Washington

The message was brief, even by the standards of Twitter/X. “I am stepping back from GrowSF,” Tweeted Garry Tan, San Francisco centi-millionaire and political provocateur. “I’m spending more time on startups and AI and in DC this year.” With that, Tan announced his exit from city politics after